Modern Architecture and Climate Design before Air Conditioning

By Daniel A. Barber. Princeton University Press, 2020, ISBN: 978-691170039.

Alan Short (University of Cambridge) reviews this book which explores the history of modern architecture from the perspective of climate, especially explaining the growing dominance of energy dependent buildings.

This book's author is an Associate Professor of Architecture at the Stuart Weitzman School of Design at the University of Pennsylvania and therefore, rather unusually and refreshingly, this is a piece of historical research about the Architecture of the relatively recent past assembled by someone with design training, albeit in the nuanced form of a Yale Masters in Environmental Design. His latest project is an exposé of profligate energy dependent buildings as de facto stranded assets in the coming zero carbon age, the subject of Mark Carney’s final speech as Governor of the Bank of England and an issue which is likely to affect the course of Architecture profoundly. It will bring into being a very different value system which will surely be used to reevaluate the potential of the existing building stock and husband the rise of what the author terms ‘Post-Carbonism’, a new style to eclipse Post-Modernism.

What might this Post-Carbon architecture be like? Barber’s latest book Modern Architecture and Climate Design before Air Conditioning sets the context for the present conundrum, the rise of the lightweight glassy tower and various architectural attempts to counter the climate-induced ill consequences for their occupants’ enjoyment of them. He places his account into the loose tendency he identifies as a revisionist history of modernism, unthinkable and foolhardy only forty years ago. It is a partial history of Modern Architecture from the perspective of climate, a theme not so thoroughly pursued since the late 1940s flurry of books on climate as a driver of health, energy, ‘civilisation’, productivity and good and bad behaviours. He attacks his subject, a carefully identified body of intentionally climate-modifying modernist works, through three interconnected themes: climate, the facade and comfort. He describes comfort as ‘the hinge’ which will ultimately and inevitably provoke the invention of an authentic and productive Post-Carbon Architecture. Can we read the examples he provides as exemplars for this future Architecture, at least as works in progress? We need to read on.

Barber identifies Pietro Belluschi’s 1947 Equitable Insurance Building in Portland Oregon as the first fully sealed, curtain walled building to be wholly reliant on air conditioning. Belluschi subcontracted the making of an acceptable indoor environment to air conditioning engineers in its entirety. Le Corbusier with his collaborator Gustave Lyon, the acoustician, attempted to home build sophisticated, yet misconceived, one-off building scale environmental solutions. These include the mur neutralisant, never fully realized but doomed on paper by the physics of the natural world and, at the Cité-Refuge de L’Armé du Salut, so malfunctioning as William Curtis tells us, to provoke a police warning. Curtis’s account of the same episode suggests that the author is giving us a rather rose-tinted version of the story of Xenakis’ hurried design for the corrective brise soleil which finally led to a police discharge for his employer. In Moscow the proposed mur neutralisant earned the contempt of the Soviets, Molotov no less, reinforced by an elaborately polite but damning letter from the Detroit-based American Blower Corporation, discovered by Rosa Urbano Gutiérrez, uncatalogued in the Paris archive.

Barber very perceptively interprets Le Corbusier’s interventions into his own office’s façade designs by the early 1930s as, ’a fraught attempt to modernize traditional means for climate management – to technologize the louvres, screens, blinds, extended eaves, and many other techniques that have been used to shade interiors for centuries’ (p.39). An extreme reluctance by designers of a certain on-trend ilk to besmirch the seamless membranes that technological refinements have made possible with the bric-a-brac of external sun shading is still very evident today, witness Zaha Hadid’s practice’s baffling all glass OPUS building in Dubai.

It is quite a shock to see the arch environmental determinist Ellsworth Huntington’s map showing The Distribution of Human Energy on the basis of Climate’ reproduced with almost no comment. It is Figure 26B in Huntington’s 1919 apologia for German First World War aggression, ‘Germany and her Neighbours’ (Ch.XIII) in World-Power and Evolution. It has not yet become ‘The Distribution of Human Health and Energy on the Basis of Climate’ as quoted from the 1924 edition which invites a more benign interpretation.  In fact it is a deliberately racist rant and the sister map (Figure 26A) purports to show ‘The Distribution of Civilization’ very much to the disadvantage of all inhabitants of warmer climates, not least Asia and Africa. Huntington’s very popular books were published by Yale University Press, not their finest moment. Here there is perhaps a touch of naivety in Barber’s commentary. The colonial powers were deeply concerned for the moral welfare of their envoys sent out to warmer and especially more humid environments which were thought to engender moral degradation. The geographer Rätzel’s concept of  Anthropogeography was corrupted by his pupil Ellen Semple so that by 1911 she was publishing well-received work on ‘Temperature and race temperament’ and the ‘Temperate zone as cradle of civilisation’. From her Anthropogeographical perspective, air conditioning could export the cool temperate climate to envelope all decent Westerners and even rescue a small number of trusted locals and it was necessary to make the Modern Architecture Barber focusses on, habitable.

The author focuses on concrete framed slabs dressed in heavy concrete meshes with lighter weight infill panels, ‘Brutalism light’. The all-glass buildings which have come to characterize global business and which really do threaten the arrival of Post-Carbon Architecture derive from another source, the phantasmological Glasarchitektur of the poet Scheerbart’s prewar Berlin, in large part ironic, but accidentally tipped into the milieu of undiscriminating American industrial knowhow by the exiled Mies van der Rohe. A single image of the model of his Friedrichstrasse tower was the rapacious bacillus, the super-spreader which fuelled the pandemic of late modern glassy architecture, the future stranded assets of our built environment.

The book is strongest on the American post-war experience. Neutra’s school classroom innovations in Puerto Rico, published in the June 1946 L'Architecture d’Aujourd'hui showing how ‘airborne germs are blown out’, come to nothing. Harrison and Ambrowitz’s sealed air conditioned Havana embassy eclipsed bioclimatic design. US embassy designs acquired unproven screens across glazed facades consciously attuned to the local vernacular to expedite local appreciation of the ‘New Look’ foreign policy. As Koenigsberger and Fry established the Tropical Architecture unit in London's Architectural Association, American military climate scientists started to go public on the importance of their new grasp of microclimate. Landsberg’s study of climate-driven site selection appeared in Architectural Forum, indistinguishable from an air force bombing map. James Marston Fitch was trained as a military weather forecaster. His House Beautiful’s ‘Climate Control Project’ started well but descended into xenophobic attacks on the European modern movement, Mies and Corbusier’s ‘Cult of Austerity’, a ‘Threat to the Next America’ featured in the April 1953 issue. The Hungarian bioclimaticists the Olgyay brothers at Princeton (funded, we discover, by the Guggenheim Foundation) pursued the quantification of comfort and environmental response in the Gropius manner. The 1952 Building Research Advisory Board exposed the long standing conundrum, the condition of the human being as a ‘uniform sociophysiological entity’, globally, the Olgyays’ proposition as opposed to the regionally adapted citizen celebrating difference. The discussion degenerated into gender and racial bias. Clarence Mills was recorded saying, ‘As anyone knows who has taken a wife  (to the tropics)…. It hurts the women’ (p.211). Racial differences in heat tolerances were credited to nutrition, health and incentivization, whatever that meant. Environmental determinism had become so discredited that mention of a suspected climate associated difference became inadmissable. Owen Lattimore and Gordon Manley lampooned Huntington’s theory, laughing at his, … romantic explanation of hordes of erratic nomads, ready to start for lost horizons at the joggle of a barometer in search of suddenly vanishing pastures’ (Manley, 1944, p.220). In any case the universal availability of air conditioning had evaporated that awkward suspicion. By page 263 we are introduced to the concept of adaptive comfort proposing that short, medium and long term habituation within rising or falling running mean temperatures induced a much more complex dynamic sense of comfort challenging all hard line bioclimatic modernist design principles. We have been looking at historical oddities not prescient harbingers of a Post Carbon future.

References

Manley, G. (1944). Some recent contributions to the study of climatic change, Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society, 70, 197-220.

Latest Peer-Reviewed Journal Content

Journal Content

Implications of urban expansion: land, planning and housing in Lagos
B Oyalowo

Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home
L K Aagaard & L V Madsen

Attuning smart home scripts to household and energy care
D Chambers

Modern methods of construction: reflections on the current research agenda [editorial]
S D Green

Masculine roles and practices in homes with photovoltaic systems
M Mechlenborg & K Gram-Hanssen

Brokering Gender Empowerment in Energy Access in the Global South
A Schiffer, M Greene, R Khalid, C Foulds, C A Vidal, M Chatterjee, S Dhar-Bhattacharjee, N Edomah, O Sule, D Palit & A N Yesutanbul

Housing adaptability: new research, emerging practices and challenges [editorial]
S Pelsmakers & E Warwick

Living in an Active Home: household dynamics and unintended consequences
F Shirani, K O’Sullivan, K Henwood, R Hale & N Pidgeon

Institutionalisation of urban climate adaptation: three municipal experiences in Spain
M Olazabal & V Castán Broto

Energy housekeeping: intersections of gender, domestic labour and technologies
R Martin

Speculation beyond technology: building scenarios through storytelling
R M Dowsett, M S Green & C F Harty

Professional judgement: an institutional logic approach to contractor tender pricing
D Jefferies & L Schweber

Emerging technologies’ impacts on ‘man caves’ and their energy demand
Y Strengers, K Dahlgren & L Nicholls

The gender of smart charging
S Pink

Fire performance and regulatory considerations with modern methods of construction
B J Meacham

Who cares? How care practices uphold the decentralised energy order
K Lucas-Healey, H Ransan- Cooper, H Temby & A W Russell

Alternatives to air-conditioning: policies, design, technologies, behaviours [editorial]
B Ford, D Mumovic & R Rawal

Benchmarking energy performance: indicators and models for Dutch housing associations
H S van der Bent, H J Visscher, A Meijer & N Mouter

Emissions from a net-zero building in India: life cycle assessment
M Jain & R Rawal

Lack of adaptability in Brazilian social housing: impacts on residents
S B Villa, P B Vasconcellos, K C R de Bortoli & L B de Araujo

Participation in domestic energy retrofit programmes: key spatio- temporal drivers
E Mohareb, A Gillich & D Bristow

Embodied carbon of concrete in buildings, Part 2: are the messages accurate?
A Moncaster, T Malmqvist, T Forman, F Pomponi & J Anderson

An alternative approach to delivering safe, sustainable surgical theatre environments
C A Short, A W Woods, L Drumright, R Zia & N Mingotti

Adapting owner-occupied dwellings in the UK: lessons for the future
T Hipwood

Integrating low energy cooling & ventilation strategies in Indian residences
M J Cook, Y Shukla, R Rawal, C Angelopoulos, L Caruggi-De-Faria, D Loveday, E Spentzou, & J Patel

Balconies as adaptable spaces in apartment housing
T Peters & S Masoudinejad

See all

Join Our Community

Latest Commentaries

Clothing: The First Layer of Personal Comfort

Alongside personal comfort systems (PCS) devices, clothing is another key site for (re)design in a body-centred personal comfort paradigm. Janine Morley (Lancaster University) explains how clothing and PCS could transform how thermal comfort is achieved whilst delivering energy savings and, potentially, increased satisfaction.

Can Personal Carbon Allowances Help Cities Reach Their Climate Targets?

Many cities throughout the world have set carbon and / or energy targets including renewable energy production and emissions reduction goals. Despite the commitment to take action, cities do not directly control the majority of the uses of energy or consumption-related sources of carbon emissions within their boundaries. Could a focus on household energy use, personal travel and consumption of material goods help to achieve this transition at city level? Tina Fawcett (University of Oxford), Kerry Constabile (University of Oxford) and Yael Parag (Reichman University) consider whether and how cities could harness personal carbon allowances in a practical manner.