Energy Fables: Challenging Ideas in the Energy Sector

Edited by Jenny Rinkinen, Elizabeth Shove, and Jacopo Torriti. Routledge, 2019, ISBN: 9780367027797.

Mithra Moezzi (QQForward) applauds this short, powerful book for revealing how many current energy discourses are framed and their limitations. The authors provide constructive, inspiring approaches that will help us to better understand and reframe energy practices, research and policies. 

Energy Fables sees the energy efficiency profession as being guided by a constellation of shared concepts, words, and short stories “worn smooth through use and submerged within familiar discourses in government, and well as in research and teaching” (p. 1). These are building blocks of communication, problem definition, and solutions in the field, creating “fables” that “sustain and reproduce a body of ideas about what is normal and about what drives change” (p. 124). As the problems addressed by the profession continue to expand from achieving energy efficiency as defined in the past to the much larger scale and ambitions of climate change policy, the authors argue, limitations of these traditional concepts have become clearer and more consequential.

Eleven example fables are taken on in this edited volume. Each gets its own chapter, none longer than ten pages. The chapters are readable separately versus a full read of the book. The collection begins with how fundamentals (energy demand, energy efficiency, and energy services) are defined and deployed. It then turns to ideas about energy dynamics (rebound, elasticity) and to common “injunctions” (“keep the lights on,” “pick the low hanging-fruit,” and promote Smart Homes) and finally to broad policy themes (the energy trilemma, flexibility, and focus on energy versus non-energy policy as the main vehicle for influencing change). An introduction and postscript bracket the fable chapters. As seen in a traditional concept of folklore, these fables reinforce existing culture while also serving as devices for debate.

Each fable is analyzed to reveal aspects of the worldview it reflects and as to how it directs policy and research. From there, the authors challenge the fable and directions it carries regarding energy problems, and then suggest the beginnings of new approaches and perspectives that edge past current limitations to better serve climate change policy. For example, the term “rebound” brings with it the idea of bouncing off a hypothetical hard world where a new technology would have no impact on the energy services demanded, with a bounce-back representing recovery of part of the value of this efficiency via increased levels of energy services (p. 40). Despite research attention to nailing down estimates of rebound effects, measurability issues keep these exercises limited. While those estimates can still be useful, chapter author Greg Marsden argues, rather than remaining bogged down by inherent limitations of rebound estimation, a next move is opened up by recognizing that rebound is an incomplete expression of the effects of any new technology. For some readers, the moves highlighting new approaches or perspectives throughout the chapters may appear subtle. And the authors do not intend to be prescriptive. Bit by bit, however, these ventures outside conventional terms of debate inject permeability into existing energy efficiency professional culture and give glimpses of something promising and new.

Beyond the analyses of the specific topics covered, one ideal outcome of this book would be for readers throughout the energy efficiency profession to realize the folkloric (and “false”) nature of many phrases and concepts of the field. These could then be seen not just as convenient communication standards or reflections of the immediate problems faced (e.g. “get people to adopt this technology”), but as gateways shaping what is assumed, how problems are defined, and what is visible, invisible, disallowed, or out of scope.

An outstanding aspect of this book is that it is designed to be read: compact (130 pp.), straightforward writing and easy to parse. This makes it accessible to a wide range of readers, including policymakers, advanced postgraduate students, and energy professionals from various disciplines who could keep it and share it as a reference book. Energy social scientists will likely be familiar with parts of many of these arguments, but the slim collection is convenient and could easily inspire broader conversations across disciplines or roles. Aiding such conversations, the book does not have a critical tone but a matter of fact one, with a clear recognition that fables are not just matters of individual commitments and convictions.

The final chapter is a powerful summary of where this leaves us. Policymakers and researchers can probably not “change their spots” quickly, the editors note. Rather, current fables are a default set of shared (though not universally believed or embraced) understandings built into everyday work and group culture, held into place by many factors —politics, markets, quantitative models, funding and reporting templates and formulae, the need for measurability, etc. While acknowledging these difficulties, this book takes an important step in encouraging more open conversations about the conflicts these fables highlight and the possibilities for adapting energy work to new scientific and practical challenges and possibilities.

Latest Peer-Reviewed Journal Content

Journal Content

Implications of urban expansion: land, planning and housing in Lagos
B Oyalowo

Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home
L K Aagaard & L V Madsen

Attuning smart home scripts to household and energy care
D Chambers

Modern methods of construction: reflections on the current research agenda [editorial]
S D Green

Masculine roles and practices in homes with photovoltaic systems
M Mechlenborg & K Gram-Hanssen

Brokering Gender Empowerment in Energy Access in the Global South
A Schiffer, M Greene, R Khalid, C Foulds, C A Vidal, M Chatterjee, S Dhar-Bhattacharjee, N Edomah, O Sule, D Palit & A N Yesutanbul

Housing adaptability: new research, emerging practices and challenges [editorial]
S Pelsmakers & E Warwick

Living in an Active Home: household dynamics and unintended consequences
F Shirani, K O’Sullivan, K Henwood, R Hale & N Pidgeon

Institutionalisation of urban climate adaptation: three municipal experiences in Spain
M Olazabal & V Castán Broto

Energy housekeeping: intersections of gender, domestic labour and technologies
R Martin

Speculation beyond technology: building scenarios through storytelling
R M Dowsett, M S Green & C F Harty

Professional judgement: an institutional logic approach to contractor tender pricing
D Jefferies & L Schweber

Emerging technologies’ impacts on ‘man caves’ and their energy demand
Y Strengers, K Dahlgren & L Nicholls

The gender of smart charging
S Pink

Fire performance and regulatory considerations with modern methods of construction
B J Meacham

Who cares? How care practices uphold the decentralised energy order
K Lucas-Healey, H Ransan- Cooper, H Temby & A W Russell

Alternatives to air-conditioning: policies, design, technologies, behaviours [editorial]
B Ford, D Mumovic & R Rawal

Benchmarking energy performance: indicators and models for Dutch housing associations
H S van der Bent, H J Visscher, A Meijer & N Mouter

Emissions from a net-zero building in India: life cycle assessment
M Jain & R Rawal

Lack of adaptability in Brazilian social housing: impacts on residents
S B Villa, P B Vasconcellos, K C R de Bortoli & L B de Araujo

Participation in domestic energy retrofit programmes: key spatio- temporal drivers
E Mohareb, A Gillich & D Bristow

Embodied carbon of concrete in buildings, Part 2: are the messages accurate?
A Moncaster, T Malmqvist, T Forman, F Pomponi & J Anderson

An alternative approach to delivering safe, sustainable surgical theatre environments
C A Short, A W Woods, L Drumright, R Zia & N Mingotti

Adapting owner-occupied dwellings in the UK: lessons for the future
T Hipwood

Integrating low energy cooling & ventilation strategies in Indian residences
M J Cook, Y Shukla, R Rawal, C Angelopoulos, L Caruggi-De-Faria, D Loveday, E Spentzou, & J Patel

Balconies as adaptable spaces in apartment housing
T Peters & S Masoudinejad

See all

Join Our Community

Latest Commentaries

Clothing: The First Layer of Personal Comfort

Alongside personal comfort systems (PCS) devices, clothing is another key site for (re)design in a body-centred personal comfort paradigm. Janine Morley (Lancaster University) explains how clothing and PCS could transform how thermal comfort is achieved whilst delivering energy savings and, potentially, increased satisfaction.

Can Personal Carbon Allowances Help Cities Reach Their Climate Targets?

Many cities throughout the world have set carbon and / or energy targets including renewable energy production and emissions reduction goals. Despite the commitment to take action, cities do not directly control the majority of the uses of energy or consumption-related sources of carbon emissions within their boundaries. Could a focus on household energy use, personal travel and consumption of material goods help to achieve this transition at city level? Tina Fawcett (University of Oxford), Kerry Constabile (University of Oxford) and Yael Parag (Reichman University) consider whether and how cities could harness personal carbon allowances in a practical manner.