www.buildingsandcities.org/insights/commentaries/mainstreaming-research-agendas.html
Why research funders, institutions and academics need to frame research agendas that are locally responsive
Samuel Laryea (University of the Witwatersrand) considers the contribution of researchers in developing countries to the discourse in Q1 journals. Common themes are evident in both developed and developing regions. However, publications from African countries appear to only partially address prevalent issues in the region, with limited publications that explore local contexts.
Roughly 20% of the papers in top-ranked journals originate from developing countries generally, and roughly 5% originate from African countries specifically. These papers have so far made interesting contributions but relatively little impact in influencing the direction of research agendas and trends in top journals. Researchers in developing countries are likely to generate greater impact in the mainstream literature through studies that are locally responsive from an innovation perspective and globally competitive from a theoretical perspective.
Globally, a look at the 105,000+ papers, published between 2020 and 2024, in 50 Q1 journals (see Appendix 1) indexed by Scimago in the building and construction category shows these have been dominated by contributions from the Global North. The overall focus has been on themes relating to sustainability, technology, and urban planning. The research agendas in the past five years have been driven by 5 main global societal needs and imperatives:
Conversely, the 20% of publications in top ranked journals from developing countries have focused broadly on six main areas:
The 5% of publications in top ranked journal from African countries focus broadly on six areas:
The evidence in Appendix 1 shows that developing and African countries have contributed approximately 20% and 5% of papers respectively in leading Q1 journals in the built environment field between 2020 and 2024. There may be different reasons behind this wide gap between the quantity of contributions from developed and developing countries, including availability and types of funding, and differences in institutions and research landscapes.
In summary, there are common themes across both developed and developing regions which more closely align to global societal needs and imperatives, including sustainability, energy and digitalisation which are. However, publications from African countries appear to only partially address prevalent issues in the region, with limited publications exploring local contexts of poor economic environment, funding for infrastructure, technological capacity, conflict and security, politics and corruption.
Three main points arise from Appendix 1:
The significant overlap between the research themes in publications from developed and developing countries shows a considerable influence of global research agendas, which raises a vital point about local and regional research issues. Research should be locally responsive to the unique contexts of its environment, and globally competitive on a theoretical level, as Professor Adam Habib explains;
"Being world-class requires not the imitation of the foreign, but the conquering of the local, and the theorisation of this to the global. It is the responsiveness to one's contextual specificities that enhances the ability of researchers in developing countries to make unique contributions to the global corpus of knowledge and become globally competitive".
In their bid to align with the global discourse in key journals, some researchers in developing countries simply imitate some of the global research agendas and use this as a basis to propose solutions to local problems. Examples of this can be seen in the areas of sustainability strategies; performance improvement of construction materials; and climate change adaptation approaches. However,
Looking forward, merely outputting more papers will not necessarily generate a greater impact in the mainstream literature. The significant scale of infrastructure provision required to accelerate development in developing countries, and the relatively poor economic environment defined by the World Bank, suggests the need for research funders, institutions and academics to frame research agendas that are locally responsive from an innovation perspective and globally competitive from a theoretical perspective. Such studies are likely to generate more impact and following of international counterparts from developed countries seeking new insights and theories compared to those that merely imitate the research agendas in developed countries without responsiveness to local considerations. The publications from African countries on indigenous materials and traditional building methods, and local adaptations of digitalisation and innovation in the construction sector are positive signs that some shift is occurring which bodes well for elevating the impact of research from developing countries.
Q1 Journals in Building & Construction subject category (Scimago) (2020 - 2024)
SN |
Journal name |
Papers 2024 |
Papers 2023 |
Papers 2022 | Papers 2021 | Papers 2020 |
TOTAL (2020-2024) |
01 |
Applied Energy |
2120 |
1569 |
1823 |
1262 |
1733 |
8507 |
02 |
Automation in Construction |
535 |
428 |
550 |
462 |
364 |
2339 |
03 |
Building and Environment |
873 |
1030 |
1130 |
832 |
754 |
4619 |
04 |
Building Research and Information |
42 |
82 |
56 |
52 |
60 |
292 |
05 |
Building Simulation |
93 |
143 |
135 |
123 |
97 |
591 |
06 |
Buildings and Cities |
23 |
57 |
63 |
53 |
42 |
238 |
07 |
Cement and Concrete Composites |
374 |
398 |
445 |
356 |
323 |
1896 |
08 |
Cement and Concrete Research |
245 |
231 |
304 |
258 |
244 |
1282 |
09 |
Construction and Building Materials |
3139 |
4133 |
3607 |
4042 |
3576 |
18497 |
10 |
Construction Innovation |
78 |
144 |
75 |
50 |
31 |
378 |
11 |
Construction Management and Economics |
46 |
64 |
60 |
58 |
75 |
303 |
12 |
Developments in the Built Environment |
102 |
189 |
40 |
26 |
31 |
388 |
13 |
Energy |
2411 |
4008 |
3354 |
2463 |
2316 |
14552 |
14 |
Energy and Buildings |
677 |
953 |
848 |
822 |
706 |
4006 |
15 |
Energy and Built Environment |
57 |
95 |
41 |
40 |
40 |
273 |
16 |
Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management |
203 |
464 |
221 |
99 |
196 |
1183 |
17 |
Georisk |
59 |
67 |
49 |
23 |
20 |
218 |
18 |
Indoor Air |
42 |
41 |
242 |
180 |
103 |
608 |
19 |
International Journal of Construction Management |
221 |
327 |
274 |
93 |
76 |
991 |
20 |
International Journal of Refrigeration |
245 |
379 |
299 |
397 |
374 |
1694 |
21 |
Journal of Building Engineering |
1143 |
2694 |
1949 |
1634 |
775 |
8195 |
22 |
Journal of Building Performance Simulation |
43 |
58 |
48 |
41 |
52 |
242 |
23 |
Journal of Composites for Construction |
76 |
89 |
100 |
80 |
106 |
451 |
24 |
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management |
172 |
218 |
200 |
250 |
214 |
1054 |
25 |
Journal of Earthquake Engineering |
118 |
250 |
358 |
121 |
101 |
948 |
26 |
Journal of Information Technology in Construction |
42 |
38 |
53 |
56 |
31 |
220 |
27 |
Materials and Structures |
212 |
181 |
239 |
228 |
146 |
1006 |
28 |
Smart and Sustainable Built Environment |
98 |
117 |
75 |
31 |
50 |
371 |
28 |
Structural Control and Health Monitoring |
108 |
143 |
278 |
184 |
167 |
880 |
30 |
Structural safety |
69 |
66 |
61 |
81 |
72 |
349 |
31 |
Structure and Infrastructure Engineering |
132 |
225 |
138 |
106 |
128 |
729 |
32 |
Structures |
998 |
1987 |
1248 |
1192 |
686 |
6111 |
33 |
Sustainable and resilient infrastructure |
59 |
69 |
55 |
22 |
29 |
234 |
34 |
Thin-Walled Structures |
876 |
1009 |
788 |
761 |
591 |
4025 |
35 |
Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology |
423 |
575 |
450 |
452 |
377 |
2277 |
36 |
Sustainable Structures |
8 |
12 |
10 |
10 |
0 |
40 |
37 |
Underground Space (China) |
86 |
101 |
74 |
62 |
27 |
350 |
38 |
Journal of Road Engineering |
21 |
25 |
20 |
4 |
0 |
70 |
39 |
Journal of Structural Engineering |
209 |
252 |
308 |
340 |
383 |
1492 |
40 |
RILEM Technical Letters |
10 |
14 |
20 |
20 |
20 |
84 |
41 |
Journal of Constructional Steel Research |
432 |
486 |
540 |
514 |
502 |
2474 |
42 |
Journal of Bridge Engineering |
107 |
149 |
165 |
152 |
141 |
714 |
43 |
Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering |
197 |
250 |
280 |
238 |
243 |
1208 |
44 |
Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering |
542 |
640 |
507 |
523 |
506 |
2718 |
45 |
Structural Concrete |
338 |
480 |
253 |
326 |
200 |
1597 |
46 |
Civil Engineering Journal |
194 |
219 |
192 |
166 |
193 |
964 |
47 |
ACI Materials Journal |
33 |
41 |
120 |
114 |
117 |
425 |
48 |
Advances in Structural Engineering |
177 |
189 |
220 |
262 |
253 |
1101 |
49 |
International Journal of Structural Stability and Dynamics |
267 |
424 |
242 |
214 |
224 |
1371 |
50 |
Steel and Composite Structures |
119 |
159 |
184 |
220 |
213 |
895 |
|
TOTAL (Q1 journals) |
18894 |
25962 |
22791 |
20095 |
17708 |
105450 |
Analysing cold-climate urban heat islands using personal weather station data
J Taylor, C H Simpson, J Vanhatalo, H Sohail, O Brousse, & C Heaviside
Are simple models for natural ventilation suitable for shelter design?
A Conzatti, D Fosas de Pando, B Chater & D Coley
Impact of roofing materials on school temperatures in tropical Africa
E F Amankwaa, B M Roberts, P Mensah & K V Gough
Acceptability of sufficiency consumption policies by Finnish households
E Nuorivaara & S Ahvenharju
Key factors for revitalising heritage buildings through adaptive reuse
É Savoie, J P Sapinski & A-M Laroche
Cooler streets for a cycleable city: assessing policy alignment
C Tang & J Bush
Understanding the embodied carbon credentials of modern methods of construction
R O'Hegarty, A McCarthy, J O'Hagan, T Thanapornpakornsin, S Raffoul & O Kinnane
The changing typology of urban apartment buildings in Aurinkolahti
S Meriläinen & A Tervo
Embodied climate impacts in urban development: a neighbourhood case study
S Sjökvist, N Francart, M Balouktsi & H Birgisdottir
Environmental effects of urban wind energy harvesting: a review
I Tsionas, M laguno-Munitxa & A Stephan
Office environment and employee differences by company health management certification
S Arata, M Sugiuchi, T Ikaga, Y Shiraishi, T Hayashi, S Ando & S Kawakubo
Spatiotemporal evaluation of embodied carbon in urban residential development
I Talvitie, A Amiri & S Junnila
Energy sufficiency in buildings and cities: current research, future directions [editorial]
M Sahakian, T Fawcett & S Darby
Sufficiency, consumption patterns and limits: a survey of French households
J Bouillet & C Grandclément
Health inequalities and indoor environments: research challenges and priorities [editorial]
M Ucci & A Mavrogianni
Operationalising energy sufficiency for low-carbon built environments in urbanising India
A B Lall & G Sethi
Promoting practices of sufficiency: reprogramming resource-intensive material arrangements
T H Christensen, L K Aagaard, A K Juvik, C Samson & K Gram-Hanssen
Structural barriers to sufficiency: the contribution of research on elites
M Koch, K Emilsson, J Lee & H Johansson
Disrupting the imaginaries of urban action to deliver just adaptation [editorial]
V Castán-Broto, M Olazabal & G Ziervogel
Nature for resilience reconfigured: global- to-local translation of frames in Africa
K Rochell, H Bulkeley & H Runhaar
How hegemonic discourses of sustainability influence urban climate action
V Castán Broto, L Westman & P Huang
Fabric first: is it still the right approach?
N Eyre, T Fawcett, M Topouzi, G Killip, T Oreszczyn, K Jenkinson & J Rosenow
Social value of the built environment [editorial]
F Samuel & K Watson
Understanding demolition [editorial]
S Huuhka
Data politics in the built environment [editorial]
A Karvonen & T Hargreaves
Latest Commentaries
Self-Organised Knowledge Space as a Living Lab
While Living Labs are often framed as structured, institutionalised spaces for innovation, Sadia Sharmin (Habitat Forum Berlin) reinterprets the concept through the lens of grassroots urban practices. She argues that self-organised knowledge spaces can function as Living Labs by fostering situated learning, collective agency, and community resilience. The example of a Living Lab in Bangladesh provides a model pathway to civic participation and spatial justice.
Climate Mitigation & Carbon Budgets: Research Challenges
Thomas Lützkendorf (Karlsruhe Institute of Technology) explains how the research community has helped to change the climate change policy landscape for the construction and real estate sectors, particularly for mitigating GHG emissions. Evidence can be used to influence policy pathways and carbon budgets, and to develop detailed carbon strategies and implementation. A key challenge is to create a stronger connection between the requirements for individual buildings and the national reduction pathways for the built environment.